Thom Hogan stated (http://www.panohelp.com/images/bythomformula.jpg): "You can calculate the focal length of a lens at its closest focus distance by using the formula minimum_focus / ((1/reproduction_ratio) + reproduction_ratio + 2)." Theory: This is just the "thin lens formula" rewritten. So, take the "thin lens formula" and see if it can be transformed into Thom's equation: 1/f = 1/v + 1/b Convert right hand side to common denominator form: 1/f = 1/v*b/b + 1/b*v/v 1/f = b/vb + v/vb 1/f = (v+b)/(vb) Divide both sides into one (reciprocal): 1/(1/f) = 1/((v+b)/(vb)) f = (vb)/(v+b) Multiply numerator/denominator by same "v+b" value: f = (vb)*(v+b) / ((v+b)*(v+b)) f = (vb)*(v+b) / (v+b)^2 Divide numerator/denominator by same "vb" value: f = ((vb)*(v+b)/(vb)) / ((v+b)^2/(vb)) f = (v+b) / ((v+b)^2/(vb)) Multiply out: f = (v+b) / (v^2/vb + 2vb/vb + b^2/vb) Simplify: f = (v+b) / (v/b + 2 + b/v) Change v/b into b/v form: f = (v+b) / (1/(b/v) + 2 + b/v) In the thin lens diagram, the 'reproduction ratio' is image height divided by object height, and by "corresponding sides of similar triangles are proportional", the 'reproduction ratio' also equals b/v. Substitute variable: f = (v+b) / (1/reproduction_ratio + 2 + reproduction_ratio) (v+b) in the thin lens formula is the distance from the object to the image. Substitute variable: f = minimum_focus / (1/(b/v) + 2 + b/v) Therefore, the formula is just the thin lens formula, albeit just reworked. But for a thick lens, (v+b) does NOT equals to distance from the object to the image. Rather, both 'v' and 'b' are measurements from their respective principal planes. Therefore, the formula produces the wrong answer. For full details, review: http://www.panohelp.com/thinlensformula.html